Skip to main content

London Councillor Leads Misleading Campaign to Block Marilyn Manson at Wembley

The announcement that Marilyn Manson would appear as a special guest at Slipknot’s forthcoming Wembley Stadium concert has prompted a campaign to have him removed from the line-up. The campaign is being led by Anton Georgiou, a Brent councillor representing the Liberal Democrats and Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group at Brent Council. It has brought together activist organizations, attracted the support of fellow councillors from different political backgrounds, and generated a Change.org petition that has gathered more than 20,000 signatures. The campaign presents itself as an effort to stand with survivors of sexual abuse and to hold institutions accountable for the performers they choose to platform. Those are serious concerns, and the right to express opposition to a concert booking is not in question. However, an examination of the campaign’s public statements, correspondence, and petition reveals a significant problem: factual information about Manson’s civil litigation has bee...

London Councillor Leads Misleading Campaign to Block Marilyn Manson at Wembley

The announcement that Marilyn Manson would appear as a special guest at Slipknot’s forthcoming Wembley Stadium concert has prompted a campaign to have him removed from the line-up. The campaign is being led by Anton Georgiou, a Brent councillor representing the Liberal Democrats and Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group at Brent Council. It has brought together activist organizations, attracted the support of fellow councillors from different political backgrounds, and generated a Change.org petition that has gathered more than 20,000 signatures.

The campaign presents itself as an effort to stand with survivors of sexual abuse and to hold institutions accountable for the performers they choose to platform. Those are serious concerns, and the right to express opposition to a concert booking is not in question. However, an examination of the campaign’s public statements, correspondence, and petition reveals a significant problem: factual information about Manson’s civil litigation has been mixed with misleading descriptions of the legal proceedings. In particular, repeated references to being “cleared of all charges” and to a possible “conviction” at an upcoming trial give readers an inaccurate impression of the legal situation.

This is not a minor distinction. The campaign is asking the public to sign a petition and is urging a major venue to reconsider a booking on the basis of claims about legal proceedings. Those claims should be accurate.

Slipknot Announces Its Wembley Concert

On September 28, 2026, Slipknot announced its 2027 “(sic)est Stadium Tour,” which is scheduled to begin on July 3 at Wembley Stadium in London. For the Wembley concert, Marilyn Manson, Lorna Shore, and Hatebreed were announced as supporting acts. The London concert is the opening date of the tour.

The announcement prompted a mixed reaction among Slipknot fans. Some objected to Manson’s inclusion and threatened to boycott the concert, while others welcomed the choice of support act. The disagreement quickly became a subject of music-media coverage. The reaction was not uniform, and the objections expressed online should not be mistaken for the views of every Slipknot fan or prospective concertgoer.

October 1: MACS Renews Its Campaign

The campaign against Manson’s appearance at Wembley was not initiated by Georgiou alone. On October 1, Male Allies Challenging Sexism (MACS), a UK-based pro-feminist men's organization that explicitly aligns itself with the radical feminist movement, announced that it was renewing its campaign against Manson’s inclusion in a British concert.

MACS stated that it had written to the Football Association, which owns Wembley Stadium, asking it to reconsider the booking. It encouraged supporters to contact the stadium and use the campaign hashtags #NoMansonAtWembley and #NoStageForAbusers.

The organization also referred to its earlier campaign against Manson’s 2025 UK performances. It stated that, with the exception of the Brighton concert, which was cancelled by the venue citing a scheduling conflict, the remaining five concerts went ahead. MACS described the Brighton cancellation as a victory for its earlier campaign. The venue’s publicly stated reason, however, was a scheduling conflict; the cancellation should not be presented as proof that the campaign caused it.

The renewed campaign established the background for Georgiou’s subsequent intervention.

October 14: Anton Georgiou’s Video Outside Wembley

On October 14, Brent councillor Anton Georgiou published a video on his social media pages filmed outside Wembley Stadium. Georgiou, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group at Brent Council, expressed his objection to Manson’s inclusion in Slipknot’s concert.

“I was shocked to learn that Marilyn Manson has been booked to play here at Wembley, given the historic sexual abuse allegations made against him,” he said. He argued that the booking conflicted with the council’s ongoing work to tackle violence against women and girls and criticized Brent Council for not issuing a public statement about the booking.

Georgiou continued:

“The Brent Liberal Democrats are seeking a review of this decision by Wembley Stadium and we're also asking the stadium: what considerations were given to survivors of sexual abuse when this decision was made?”

In an interview with MyLondon, Georgiou expanded on his objections. He said:

“We cannot keep saying that tackling violence against women and girls is everyone’s business and then fail to ask difficult questions when it really matters. It’s disappointing that the council has not spoken out publicly about this.”

He further argued:

“The allegations against Marilyn Manson are serious, and while he denies wrongdoing, Wembley Stadium needs to explain what consideration was given to them before this booking was confirmed. It also needs to consider the message this sends to survivors of abuse.”

Georgiou also criticized what he regarded as the stadium’s response to concerns about the booking:

“Wembley is a major institution in Brent. It has a responsibility to take these concerns seriously, not hide behind generic statements about safety and inclusion. I am asking the stadium to review this booking and be open about how the decision was made.”

He concluded by insisting that his campaign was not an attempt to restrict artistic expression:

“This is not about censorship. It is about accountability, and making sure our commitment to tackling violence against women and girls means something in practice.”

The remarks were also reported by other music and news publications in the following days.

The controversy prompted responses from both Brent Council and Wembley Stadium. A Brent Council spokesperson explained that the venue and event organizers were responsible for bookings and that the council had no control over which performers were engaged. The spokesperson nevertheless reaffirmed the council’s commitment to tackling violence against women and girls, supporting survivors, and making the borough safer. The council also encouraged the headline act and event organizers to reflect carefully on feedback from Brent residents and survivors.

Wembley explained that supporting acts were selected by the headline artist and show promoter. The stadium also stated that it had initiated a conversation with the promoter about Manson’s inclusion in the concert.

These responses established that the booking was not a decision made by Brent Council and that Wembley had begun discussions with the promoter. They did not, however, resolve the campaign’s objections.

October 21: “Until They Are Cleared of All Charges”

On October 21, Georgiou issued a further public statement in response to criticism he had received. It was here that the wording of the campaign became more legally problematic.

 

Georgiou stated:

“Marilyn Manson wasn’t found not guilty when previous lawsuits were brought against him by four women - the cases were thrown out as they exceeded the statute of limitations.”

He then referred to the forthcoming trial and concluded:

“A performer who is subject to these kinds of allegations should not play at our national stadium until they are cleared of all charges.”

The first statement is misleading because it presents several legally different outcomes as though they were all dismissals based on the statute of limitations. That is not what happened. The civil proceedings brought against Manson did not all end in the same way, and the distinctions matter.

Esmé Bianco filed a federal civil lawsuit against Manson in 2021, alleging sexual assault, sexual battery, and human trafficking. That case was settled in January 2023. The settlement was not a dismissal on statute-of-limitations grounds, and its terms were not publicly disclosed. A separate civil lawsuit brought by a woman identified as Jane Doe (Chloe Black), who alleged rape, was also settled, in September 2023, shortly before the case was scheduled to go to trial. That case, too, was settled rather than thrown out because of the statute of limitations.

Another lawsuit, brought by Ashley Morgan Smithline, was dismissed without prejudice in January 2023. The dismissal followed a procedural issue: Smithline had dismissed her attorney and failed to meet the court's deadline for arranging replacement counsel. It was not a judicial determination that her allegations were true or false, nor was it a dismissal on statute-of-limitations grounds. Smithline later recanted her allegations and accused Evan Rachel Wood and others of manipulating her into making false accusations. Wood denied those claims. Smithline's recantation is relevant to the history of the case, but it should not be confused with a court ruling on the allegations.

Nor did the civil litigation end with those three cases. Two other proceedings remain relevant. One was brought by Manson's former assistant, Ashley Walters. Her case passed through several dismissals and appeals before being reinstated in January 2026 under California's AB 250 legislation, which created a temporary window for certain older sexual-assault civil claims. In June 2026, a judge rejected Manson's latest attempt to dismiss or narrow Walters' claims, allowing the case to proceed at that stage. Manson denies the allegations.

The other is the separate civil lawsuit brought by Bianca Allaine Kyne, formerly identified as Jane Doe. That proceeding also remains active. It should not be confused with the Jane Doe lawsuit that was settled in September 2023; they are separate cases.

There is also a separate lawsuit that must not be included among the cases brought against Manson by women making allegations against him. In 2022, Manson himself filed a lawsuit against Evan Rachel Wood and Illma Gore. He voluntarily dropped the lawsuit and abandoned his appeal in November 2024, agreeing to pay Wood's legal fees. This was a lawsuit initiated by Manson against Wood and Gore, not a case brought against him by an accuser.

The actual outcomes, therefore, were not that all the previous lawsuits were thrown out because they exceeded the statute of limitations. Two cases were settled; Smithline's case was dismissed without prejudice for a procedural reason, and she subsequently recanted her allegations; and the separate cases brought by Walters and Kyne remain ongoing. A settlement is not a finding of guilt, but neither is it a dismissal. 

Georgiou's second statement raises a further problem. His demand that Manson remain off the Wembley stage until he is “cleared of all charges” suggests that criminal charges are pending. However, the Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office announced on January 24, 2025, that Manson would not face criminal charges following its investigation. The office explained that the domestic-violence allegations were outside the statute of limitations and that it could not prove the sexual-assault allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. This decision did not establish that every allegation was false, nor did it resolve the separate civil proceedings. But it is important to distinguish the criminal investigation, which ended without charges, from the civil lawsuits that bring no charges, and some of which remain active.

The distinction is particularly important because Georgiou's October 21 statement was not simply an expression of concern about allegations. It invoked the language of criminal proceedings while describing the outcomes of civil lawsuits inaccurately. That same language would appear again in his October 27 letter to Wembley Stadium and, subsequently, in the Change.org petition he created.

October 27: The Letter to Wembley Stadium

On October 27, Georgiou sent a letter to Mr Lynch at Wembley Stadium, reiterating his objections to Manson’s booking. The letter described the public response to his earlier correspondence and stated that a number of campaign organizations had agreed to support him.

 

It repeated the claim that Manson “wasn’t found not guilty” in previous lawsuits and stated that he would be returning to court in November 2027 to face a jury trial.

The letter then made a particularly consequential assertion:

“If Mr Warner is convicted at the upcoming trial, this would reflect extremely badly on the stadium and risk untold reputational damage.”

This is not an accurate description of the forthcoming proceeding. The case scheduled for November 2027 is a civil lawsuit brought by Ashley Walters, Manson’s former assistant. A civil jury trial does not determine whether a defendant is criminally guilty and cannot result in a criminal conviction. It may determine whether civil liability has been established.

The letter also stated:

“In any other walk of life, an individual subject to these types of horrific allegations would be suspended from their profession, pending the outcome of a full and proper investigation.”

Georgiou concluded by urging Wembley to take a stand against continuing to platform performers such as Manson until the legal process had taken its course.

There is a legitimate debate to be had about whether a venue should book an artist while civil allegations remain unresolved. Georgiou is entitled to argue that Wembley should reconsider the booking. But that argument should not depend on describing a civil lawsuit as though it were a criminal prosecution. The distinction is fundamental, particularly when the letter itself invokes the possibility of a conviction.

The Thirteen Organizations Supporting the Campaign

The October 27 letter included the names of thirteen organizations and the individuals associated with them who had agreed to support the campaign. They were:

  1. Male Allies Challenging Sexism — Chris Green OBE and Björn Suttka

  2. No Stage for Abusers — Stephen

  3. Snap Survivors Network — Angela Walker

  4. The Model Alliance — Tracey Williams and Carre Sutton

  5. Victim’s Rights Advocacy — Lenora Claire

  6. Sexual Predator Accountability Institute — Samantha Maloney and Yara Wilde

  7. Stand With Survivors — Dr. Caroline Heldman

  8. Prosopon Healing — Dr. Hermina Nedalescu and Jovana Timnic

  9. Female Composer Safety League — Nomi Abadi

  10. Courageous Women Association — Toshonna Ross

  11. Men at Work — Michael Conroy

  12. Collective Shout — Melinda Tankard Reist

  13. Kaleidoscopic UK — Vickie Robertson BEM

The letter presents these organizations and their representatives as supporters of Georgiou’s campaign. Their involvement is significant because Georgiou subsequently emphasized the breadth of this support when publicizing his efforts. On October 30, he met with Chris Green OBE outside Wembley Stadium and stated that he had been in contact with Green and Björn Suttka since sending his first letter to the stadium. He also announced that thirteen organizations around the world now supported his campaign.

The support of these organizations, however, should be distinguished from the accuracy of the legal claims made in the campaign. Advocacy experience and legal expertise are not interchangeable, and the participation of these organizations does not, in itself, establish that the campaign’s descriptions of the legal proceedings were properly reviewed.

It should also be noted that women such as Lenora Claire and Dr. Caroline Heldman are well known within the circle of Manson's accusers. Both have established their own organizations and have directed their activism against Manson in the context of their close personal relationships with women who have accused him. Georgiou's repeated mischaracterizations of the Manson cases and allegations closely follow the same arguments and misleading characterizations that Heldman has advanced publicly. Rather than seeking independent and competent legal advice to establish the facts and understand the actual status and outcomes of the proceedings, Georgiou appears to have adopted this activist narrative and repeated its claims. The result is a campaign in which serious legal matters are presented inaccurately, with insufficient distinction between allegations and established facts, settlements and dismissals, or civil proceedings and criminal prosecutions. It is quite clear that he has not consulted a competent lawyer.

October 30: Georgiou Meets with MACS

On October 30, Georgiou published a photograph outside Wembley Stadium with Chris Green OBE of Male Allies Challenging Sexism.

 

In the accompanying post, Georgiou wrote:

“Good to meet Chris Green OBE from Male Allies Challenging Sexism in #Wembley today.”

He added:

“I’ve been in touch with Chris and his colleague Björn since sending my first letter to Wembley Stadium challenging the booking of Marilyn Manson.”

He then stated:

“I’m proud 13 organisations around the world now support my campaign.”

The post makes clear that Georgiou had been in contact with MACS since the beginning of his correspondence with Wembley and regarded the thirteen organizations as supporters of his campaign.

November 2: Representatives Appear in Support

On November 2, Georgiou publicized a further video featuring representatives of organizations supporting the campaign. Their appearance demonstrated that the effort had developed beyond an individual councillor’s objection and had become a coordinated public campaign involving several advocacy groups.

The organizations’ participation was subsequently presented as evidence of the breadth of opposition to Manson’s appearance at Wembley.

November 3: The Change.org Petition

On November 3, Georgiou launched a Change.org petition titled “No Marilyn Manson at Wembley Stadium.” The petition calls on Wembley Stadium and Live Nation to remove Manson from the planned concert.

Its description repeats the central arguments found in Georgiou’s October 21 statement and October 27 letter. It states that Manson “wasn’t found not guilty” in previous lawsuits, that he will return to court in November 2027 for a jury trial, and that he should not perform at Wembley until he is “cleared of all charges.”

It also repeats the warning:

“If Mr Warner is convicted at the upcoming trial, this would reflect extremely badly on the stadium, risk untold reputational damage and send the wrong message to survivors of sexual abuse.”

The petition contains factual information about the civil lawsuit and the allegations, and it identifies the forthcoming trial. But it combines those facts with language that gives a misleading account of the legal proceedings.

This is particularly important because the petition is not simply an archived letter or an old social-media statement. It remains publicly available and continues to solicit signatures. Its description is still being presented to prospective signatories as the basis for supporting the campaign.

The petition also states that, by signing, people add their voices to calls from more than a dozen global organizations. In this way, the campaign invokes the collective authority of those organizations while continuing to use the same misleading legal terminology.

November 4: Change.org UK Promotes the Campaign

On November 4, Change.org UK's verified Instagram account published a post promoting Anton Georgiou's petition against Marilyn Manson's appearance at Wembley Stadium. The post featured a photograph of Manson alongside the headline: “MARILYN MANSON TO PLAY WEMBLEY 4 MONTHS BEFORE SEXUAL ASSAULT CASE,” followed by the statement: “A Brent councillor’s petition asks Wembley to drop him until the case is heard.”

 

The accompanying caption stated:

“Marilyn Manson is booked to support Slipknot at Wembley Stadium on 3 July 2027. Four months later, on 15 November, he’s due before a jury in Los Angeles in a civil sexual assault lawsuit brought by his former assistant. He denies the allegations.

Brent councillor Anton Georgiou has started a petition asking Wembley and Live Nation to take him off the bill until the legal process has run its course. Thirteen domestic and sexual abuse charities have written to the stadium backing the call.

You can sign at the link in bio.”

The caption is more legally precise than some of Georgiou's earlier statements and the wording of the petition itself. It explicitly identifies the forthcoming proceeding as a civil sexual-assault lawsuit and acknowledges that Manson denies the allegations. The headline, however, reduces the matter to a “sexual assault case” without making that civil distinction.

The choice of photograph also deserves attention. The image used in the graphic dates from 2019, before Manson's reported sobriety in 2021. It was clearly supplied to Change.org by an activist. Rather than using a more recent photograph, the campaign chose an older image that presents Manson with a dishevelled appearance and an intense expression. In the context of a headline about a sexual-assault case, the photograph contributes to an unflattering and potentially prejudicial impression before readers have even considered the accompanying information. It does not establish anything about the allegations or the civil proceedings, but its selection helps frame the subject emotionally for the viewer. This is another example of how the campaign's presentation relies not only on its wording but also on its imagery to influence public perception. The use of an older photograph in this manner may reasonably be regarded as misleading visual framing.

The post is significant for another reason: the petition was no longer being circulated solely through Georgiou and the organizations supporting his campaign. Change.org UK was also giving it exposure through its own official social-media account, presenting the campaign to its followers and directing them to sign. Whether this particular publicity was part of a paid promotional arrangement or an independent editorial decision by the platform cannot be established from the post itself. 

Nevertheless, the platform's direct involvement in publicizing the campaign makes the question of how the petition gained its visibility particularly relevant, especially in light of the sudden increase in signatures recorded in November.

The Petition’s Sudden Increase in Signatures

The petition's signature history presents several points worth examining. Created on November 3, 2026, it accumulated approximately 1,755 signatures during its first eight days, reaching that figure by November 11. This relatively modest increase is particularly noteworthy because Change.org UK had already publicized the petition through its verified Instagram account on November 4, directing its followers to sign. Despite this exposure through the platform's own social-media channel, the petition did not experience any substantial increase during the days that followed.

The situation changed dramatically on November 12. According to the figures recorded in screenshots taken at the time, the petition's total suddenly rose from 1,755 signatures on November 11 to 15,062 on November 12, an increase of 13,307 signatures in approximately one day. It continued to rise, reaching 17,659 on November 13, 19,033 on November 14, and 19,759 on November 16. By November 17, it had reached 19,888, and on November 18 it passed the 20,000 mark, with 20,053 signatures.

 
The speed of this increase was striking. In a single day, the petition gained more than seven times the number of signatures it had accumulated during its first eight days. I searched for public posts, announcements, or other visible promotional activity that might explain the extraordinary increase between November 11 and 12, but could not identify a corresponding public campaign that accounted for it. This does not mean that no promotion took place. Signatures could have come through private messages, mailing lists, social-media sharing, Change.org recommendations, or other channels that are not publicly visible.

The petition's passage beyond 20,000 signatures subsequently became a publicity event in its own right. Anton Georgiou publicized the milestone, while Male Allies Challenging Sexism (MACS) also promoted the achievement as a success for the campaign. The figure was then picked up by numerous media outlets. Reports appeared in publications including The Independent, NME, Louder, The PRP, Loudwire, and others, presenting the petition's 20,000 signatures as evidence of growing opposition to Manson's appearance at Wembley. The coverage also repeated the campaign's central demand that he be removed from the concert. 

One might reasonably expect this extensive publicity, particularly when combined with the public promotion by Georgiou and MACS, to produce another substantial increase in signatures. Yet the figures recorded after the milestone tell a different story. The petition had 20,053 signatures on November 18, 20,528 on November 20, and 20,688 on November 21. Thus, despite the attention generated by the 20,000-signature milestone and the subsequent media coverage, its growth became comparatively modest. The petition gained only 635 signatures between November 18 and November 21.

The contrast is noteworthy. During its first eight days, despite Change.org UK's social-media promotion, the petition accumulated approximately 1,755 signatures. It then gained more than 13,000 in a single day. After reaching 20,000 and receiving widespread media attention, its growth slowed considerably. This pattern does not establish that the earlier surge involved artificial or manipulated signatures, nor does the slower increase afterward prove that anything improper occurred. Nevertheless, it raises legitimate questions about the sources of the original surge, the channels through which the petition was circulated, and the relationship between its apparent public momentum and the number of people who continued to sign it after the publicity.

In an effort to understand this sudden increase, I contacted Change.org by email and submitted several questions concerning the petition. I asked about the sources of the signatures, their geographical distribution, whether paid promotion or the platform's own recommendations had played a role in directing people to the petition, and what the platform means by "verified signatures." I also asked whether each signature represents a unique individual. At the time of writing, I have received no response.

These questions are particularly relevant given that Change.org UK had itself promoted the petition through its verified Instagram account on November 4. That post demonstrates that the platform gave the campaign exposure through its own social-media presence, although it does not establish whether the post was paid promotion or an independent editorial decision. The distinction is important, and clarification from Change.org would help establish how the petition acquired its visibility.

The number of signatures is repeatedly presented by the campaign and its supporters as evidence of the strength of public opposition to Manson's appearance. But a signature count alone does not reveal who signed, where they are located, how they encountered the petition, or what promotional channels brought them to it. Nor does it establish that the signatories represent the views of Wembley audiences or the local community. In fact, the relatively few comments accompanying the petition, which only number 43, reveal the ignorance of the signers of the case involved and also show that the misleading information already cited contributed to them providing their signatures. Until the questions surrounding the sudden increase and subsequent slowdown are answered, the figures should be treated with caution rather than presented as an uncomplicated measure of public opinion.

November 19: A Letter Signed by Brent Councillors

On November 19, a group of Brent councillors from different political backgrounds issued a joint letter supporting the campaign to prevent Marilyn Manson from performing at Wembley Stadium. The letter was signed by Anton Georgiou, Leader of the Brent Liberal Democrats; Muhammed Butt, Leader of Brent Council; Mary Mitchell, Leader of the Brent Green Group; Gwen Grahl, Deputy Leader of Brent Council; and other councillors representing communities across the borough.



 

The letter points to the Change.org petition, which had attracted more than 20,000 signatures, and presents this level of support as evidence of the strength of public concern. However, the councillors give considerable weight to this number without establishing what it actually represents. There is no publicly demonstrated breakdown showing how many signatories are residents of Brent, how many live elsewhere in the United Kingdom, or how many are from other countries. A petition hosted on an international platform and promoted by organizations operating internationally cannot automatically be treated as a measure of opinion among Brent residents. Nor does the number of signatures establish that the signatories represent the views of the local community or the people who would attend the concert.

The distinction matters. The councillors are elected representatives of Brent, and their intervention carries political weight precisely because of the offices they hold. They should therefore be particularly careful not to present an international petition as though it necessarily reflects the views of their constituents. Twenty thousand signatures may demonstrate that a campaign has attracted considerable attention, but they do not, by themselves, establish the geographical composition of its supporters, the reliability of the claims made in its promotion, or the extent of local opposition to the concert.

The letter also invokes the concerns of survivors and the support of organizations associated with sexual-abuse advocacy. The experiences and concerns of survivors deserve to be heard, but the description of an organization as survivor-founded or survivor-focused does not automatically establish that its positions are independent, impartial, or factually accurate. Advocacy organizations and their representatives, like any other campaigners, must be subject to scrutiny, especially when they represent radical ideologies as many listed do. Their claims do not become unquestionable simply because they are presented in the name of survivors.

The personal associations of some of the campaign's prominent supporters are also relevant context. Figures such as Lenora Claire and Dr. Caroline Heldman have close associations with women who have accused Manson and have been involved in activism against him. Those relationships help explain the personal commitments behind their participation in the campaign, but they should not be mistaken for independent corroboration of the allegations. Personal loyalty and activist commitment may shape a person's position; they do not establish the truth of every claim made by those with whom that person is aligned. The councillors should not treat the participation of such figures or the names of their organizations as a substitute for examining the evidence.

There is a further problem with the way the letter appeals to the suffering and concerns of survivors. Rather than concentrating on the factual and legal questions that should be central to a responsible assessment of the matter, it relies heavily on the emotional force of the subject. This is an appeal to emotion, and more particularly an appeal to pity: the reader is encouraged to accept the campaign's position through sympathy for those who have suffered, rather than through a careful examination of what has actually been established. The suffering of survivors is real and deserves respect, but sympathy cannot establish the accuracy of a particular allegation or resolve the legal status of a proceeding.

The letter also employs an appeal to guilt. Its moral framing places pressure on those responsible for the booking by suggesting that allowing Manson to perform would make them morally complicit in wrongdoing. The decision is thereby transformed from a question about a concert booking, the available evidence, and the status of legal proceedings into a test of moral character. This is a form of moral coercion. It is reinforced by a false dilemma: the implication that decision-makers must either accept the campaign's demands or place themselves on the side of those who disregard or tolerate abuse.

The letter's rhetoric also risks poisoning the well by associating disagreement with the campaign with indifference to women and survivors. It attempts to create a moral division between those who support the campaign and those who do not, portraying decision-makers who decline to accept its demands as opponents of women and survivors, or as people willing to tolerate the very abuses the campaign condemns. This is an unfair implication. A decision-maker can take allegations of sexual abuse seriously, respect survivors, and support efforts to combat violence against women without accepting every allegation as established fact or agreeing that Manson should be excluded from a concert. Disagreement with a campaign's conclusions is not opposition to survivors. Nor does declining to comply with its demands demonstrate indifference to violence against women.

The councillors' letter is more careful than Georgiou's October statements in one important respect. It explicitly acknowledges that allegations are not the same as convictions and that everyone is entitled to due process. It also correctly identifies the forthcoming proceedings as a civil lawsuit. These are necessary distinctions. However, the letter does not address or correct the misleading descriptions of the legal proceedings in Georgiou's earlier statements and in the still-active Change.org petition. By endorsing the campaign without confronting those inaccuracies, the councillors lend their political authority to a campaign whose public presentation has repeatedly blurred the distinction between civil allegations and criminal proceedings.

This omission is especially significant because the petition remains live and continues to solicit signatures. The misleading language is therefore not merely an error confined to an earlier letter. It remains part of the appeal being presented to prospective signatories. The councillors could have acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations while insisting that the campaign describe the legal proceedings accurately. Instead, their joint intervention gives the campaign additional political legitimacy without addressing the accuracy of the claims through which it has sought public support.

Elected representatives have a responsibility to distinguish established facts from allegations, advocacy, and emotional appeals. They should also be cautious about treating the number of signatures on an online petition as a mandate from their own constituents when the geographical composition of those signatures has not been demonstrated. The concerns of survivors deserve consideration, but they should not be used to place a campaign's assertions beyond scrutiny or to suggest that anyone who questions its arguments is an enemy of women. Respect for survivors and respect for factual accuracy are not competing obligations. Both are necessary.

The Legal Proceedings: What They Actually Establish

The central legal issue in this campaign is not difficult to explain, but it is essential to understand.

There are two distinct matters that must not be confused: the criminal investigation conducted by authorities in Los Angeles and the separate civil lawsuit brought by Ashley Walters.

On January 24, 2025, the Los Angeles County District Attorney announced that a four-year investigation into allegations of domestic violence and sexual assault had been completed. The District Attorney stated that the domestic-violence allegations fell outside the statute of limitations and that prosecutors could not prove sexual-assault charges beyond a reasonable doubt. No criminal charges were brought.

This decision did not amount to a judicial finding that all allegations were false. Nor did it resolve the separate civil proceedings. Manson has denied the allegations.

The civil lawsuit brought by Ashley Walters, his former assistant, is a separate legal matter. The case was reinstated under legislation allowing certain older sexual-assault claims to proceed. A jury trial has been scheduled for November 15, 2027. That date is a scheduled trial date, not a guarantee that the case will reach trial on that day; the proceedings may be affected by further court decisions, settlement, or other developments. In fact, in February 2027, months before the concert, the Manson's attorney's will attempt to have the case dismissed, and they foresee a positive outcome.

The distinction is straightforward:

  • A criminal prosecution concerns whether the state can prove criminal guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

  • A civil lawsuit concerns whether civil liability has been established under the applicable civil standard of proof.

  • A civil jury cannot convict someone of a crime.

  • The absence of criminal charges does not automatically dispose of a separate civil lawsuit.

Consequently, the language used in Georgiou’s October 21 statement, his October 27 letter, and the live petition is misleading when it refers to Manson needing to be “cleared of all charges” or warns that he may be “convicted” at the forthcoming civil trial.

The November 19 councillors’ letter is more accurate in this respect. It recognizes that allegations are not convictions and identifies the forthcoming proceeding as civil litigation. That is precisely the distinction that should have been maintained throughout the campaign, even though in the end it made them focus more on emotional arguments filled with logical fallacies.

Conclusion

The issue is not whether survivors deserve to be heard, whether allegations of abuse should be taken seriously, or whether Wembley has the right to reconsider its booking. The issue is whether a campaign seeking to influence public opinion and pressure a major venue has represented the facts accurately.

Georgiou and those supporting his campaign are entitled to oppose Manson's appearance. But that opposition does not justify misleading descriptions of civil proceedings, treating a civil trial as a possible criminal conviction, or using the language of criminal charges when none were brought. Nor should the invocation of survivors' suffering or the accumulation of petition signatures place the campaign's claims beyond scrutiny.

The petition remains active, and its misleading legal language continues to be presented to prospective signatories. That is a matter the campaign's organizers should address. Those who demand accountability from others must also accept responsibility for the accuracy of their own public statements.

A cause does not become more credible simply because it is presented in the name of a worthy cause. Accuracy, fairness, and accountability must apply to everyone.